Force Majeure Clauses: What Happens When a Business Cannot Perform?

A supply problem, government restriction, cyber incident or extreme weather event can make it difficult for a business to meet its contractual commitments. In some contracts, a force majeure clause may provide a route for dealing with that disruption. But the words “force majeure” do not automatically excuse a party from performing.

What does a force majeure clause do?

A force majeure clause sets out what happens when a specified event outside a party’s control affects performance of the contract. It may allow obligations to be suspended, deadlines extended or, in some cases, the contract brought to an end.

There is no single standard clause that applies to every contract. The wording matters: one agreement may cover a defined list of events, while another may set out a broader test. The clause may also specify how serious the impact must be, how quickly the affected party must notify the other side, and what steps must be taken to reduce the disruption.

A business should therefore avoid assuming that an event qualifies simply because it was unexpected or outside its control. It needs to check whether the event and its effects fall within the clause.

Does the event actually prevent performance?

A key question is whether the event has caused the failure to perform the obligation in question. A general increase in costs, inconvenience or loss of profitability may not be enough if the contract requires a more direct impact.

For example, a supplier facing a shortage might need to show how that shortage prevents or delays the promised delivery. A business that can still perform through another route may need to consider whether the contract or clause requires it to do so.

The Supreme Court considered the interpretation of a force majeure clause in RTI Ltd v MUR Shipping BV. It held that, without clear wording, a reasonable-endeavours requirement did not require a party to accept a non-contractual alternative form of performance. The decision highlights why businesses should read the clause carefully and avoid assuming that a proposed workaround must be accepted, or that an alternative can be rejected without considering the wording.

What should a business do when disruption occurs?

The first step is to identify the affected contractual obligation and review the relevant clause. Check what events it covers, what level of impact is required, and what notice the contract requires. Pay close attention to deadlines, the person or address to notify, and any required form of notice.

Keep evidence of the disruption and its effect. Depending on the situation, that might include supplier communications, delivery records, incident reports, official notices or correspondence with customers. A clear record can help explain why performance was affected and what steps were taken in response.

The affected party should also consider whether it can reduce the impact. This might involve alternative suppliers, revised delivery dates or a temporary change to the way services are provided. The contract may say what steps are required, so a business should not rely on informal assumptions about what counts as reasonable.

Communication matters too. A prompt, accurate notice can help both sides plan, while silence may create further costs or damage the commercial relationship. Businesses should avoid saying that a contract is “cancelled” or that they are “not liable” before they have reviewed their rights and obligations.

Drafting a clause before a disruption happens

Businesses negotiating contracts can reduce uncertainty by making the clause specific to the relationship. Consider:

  • Which events should be included, and whether the list should be exhaustive.
  • What effect the event must have on performance.
  • How and when notice must be given.
  • Whether the affected party must use reasonable efforts to limit disruption.
  • Whether affected obligations are suspended, deadlines extended or fees adjusted.
  • How long the disruption can continue before either party may terminate.
  • What happens to payments, work already completed and customer data when the contract ends.

A clause should reflect how the business actually operates. A customer-facing service agreement, a construction contract and a supply agreement may need different provisions.

How Penerley can help

Penerley advises businesses on commercial contracts, contractual disputes and risk management. If disruption is affecting a contract, or you want to review your terms before a problem arises, contact Penerley to discuss your options.

Share the Post: