Assigning a Commercial Lease: What Tenants Should Check First

A business may need to leave premises before its commercial lease expires. If the lease allows it, one option may be to assign the lease to a new tenant. Assignment transfers the tenant’s leasehold interest to someone else, but it does not necessarily end the outgoing tenant’s responsibilities immediately.

Start with the lease

The lease is the first place to check. It may prohibit assignment, allow it only with the landlord’s consent, or set conditions that must be satisfied before the transfer can take place. It may also distinguish between assigning the whole premises and assigning only part.

Do not assume that a landlord’s informal agreement is enough. The lease may require a formal application, supporting documents and written consent. Completing an assignment without the consent required by the lease could amount to a breach.

Government guidance also notes that whether a commercial lease can be assigned depends on its terms and that landlord permission may be required.

What information might the landlord need?

A landlord will often want to understand whether the proposed assignee can meet the lease obligations. An application may include information about the incoming tenant’s business, finances and proposed use of the premises. The landlord may also ask for references or details about the assignee’s experience.

Prepare the information early. Delays can arise if documents are missing or if the proposed business use is unclear. The lease may contain its own process and timeframe, so the tenant should review those provisions before agreeing a completion date with the incoming tenant.

Can the landlord refuse consent?

The answer depends on the lease and the statutory rules that apply. Under section 19 of the Landlord and Tenant Act 1927, a lease covenant requiring consent to assignment is generally subject to a proviso that consent is not to be unreasonably withheld. The wording and circumstances still need to be considered.

Where the consent covenant is qualified by a requirement that consent must not be unreasonably withheld, the Landlord and Tenant Act 1988 imposes duties on the person who can give consent. Following a written application, they must act within a reasonable time and provide written notice of their decision. If consent is refused, they must give reasons; if it is granted subject to conditions, those conditions should be stated.

A tenant should not assume that a landlord’s delay or refusal is automatically unlawful. The application needs to be properly made, and the lease wording and proposed assignee’s circumstances may be relevant. If the decision is causing difficulty, get advice before completing the transfer or taking steps that could breach the lease.

Will the outgoing tenant still be liable?

Potentially. The position depends on the lease, when it was granted and the terms of the consent. In some cases, the landlord may require the outgoing tenant to enter into an authorised guarantee agreement (AGA), guaranteeing the incoming tenant’s performance of certain lease obligations. Section 16 of the Landlord and Tenant (Covenants) Act 1995 sets out the statutory framework for an AGA.

An AGA can leave the former tenant exposed if the assignee fails to meet the obligations it has guaranteed. Before agreeing to one, the tenant should understand its scope, when it ends and what liabilities it covers. Any proposed guarantee should be reviewed alongside the lease and the landlord’s consent conditions.

Assignment or subletting?

Assignment and subletting are different. With an assignment, the incoming tenant takes over the lease. With a subletting, the original tenant remains the tenant under the main lease and grants another party the right to occupy all or part of the premises. The original tenant generally remains responsible to the landlord for the main lease obligations, including rent, even if the subtenant does not pay.

The right option depends on the lease, the business’s plans and how much ongoing responsibility it is prepared to retain. In either case, check the consent requirements before agreeing terms with another occupier.

Practical steps before you proceed

Before making an application, review the lease, confirm the proposed assignee’s intended use and gather the information the landlord is likely to request. Allow time for consent and legal documentation, and understand any conditions, costs or continuing liabilities before committing to a transfer date.

How Penerley can help

Penerley advises landlords and tenants on commercial leases, consent applications and lease transfers. If you are considering assigning or subletting business premises, contact Penerley to review the lease and help you understand the process.

Share the Post: