When parents separate, decisions about children are often the most sensitive and emotionally challenging issues to resolve. Disagreements about where a child should live, how much time they should spend with each parent, or how major decisions should be made can quickly become complex. In England and Wales, a Child Arrangements Order provides a legal framework to clarify these arrangements where agreement cannot be reached.
The court’s focus in every case is the welfare of the child. The legal system is designed to prioritise stability, safety, and emotional wellbeing above all else. Understanding how Child Arrangements Orders work can help parents approach disputes constructively and with greater clarity.
What Is a Child Arrangements Order
A Child Arrangements Order is made under the Children Act 1989. It regulates who a child lives with, who they spend time with, and the nature of that contact. The order replaced the previous concepts of residence and contact orders and is intended to reflect modern parenting arrangements more flexibly.
A Child Arrangements Order can cover detailed matters, including:
-
Where the child will live
-
How much time they spend with each parent
-
Arrangements for school holidays and special occasions
-
Indirect contact such as phone calls or video calls
-
Handover arrangements between parents
The order can be tailored to suit the specific needs of the child and the family. In some cases, children may spend substantial time with both parents. In others, one parent may have primary care while the other has defined contact.
Before applying to court, most applicants must attend a Mediation Information and Assessment Meeting. This requirement is designed to encourage parents to resolve disputes outside of court wherever possible. Mediation can often lead to workable agreements that avoid the stress, cost, and delay of litigation. There are exemptions to this requirement, particularly in cases involving domestic abuse or urgency.
How the Court Decides Child Arrangements
If agreement cannot be reached, the Family Court will determine the arrangements. The child’s welfare is the court’s paramount consideration. This principle underpins all decisions relating to children in England and Wales.
Judges apply what is known as the welfare checklist. This includes several key factors:
-
The wishes and feelings of the child, considered in light of their age and understanding
-
The child’s physical, emotional, and educational needs
-
The likely effect of any change in circumstances
-
The age, sex, background, and relevant characteristics of the child
-
Any risk of harm or history of harm
-
The capability of each parent to meet the child’s needs
The court does not automatically favour mothers over fathers, nor does it assume that equal time is always appropriate. Each case is decided on its own facts. The primary aim is to ensure the child grows up in a stable, secure, and supportive environment.
Judges are generally reluctant to make orders unless necessary. If parents can agree arrangements themselves, the court may consider that preferable. However, where conflict is significant or safeguarding concerns arise, a formal order may be required to provide certainty.
The Court Process in Practice
Where court proceedings are necessary, an application is made to the Family Court. Once issued, the court timetable begins. Cafcass, the Children and Family Court Advisory and Support Service, is usually involved at an early stage. Cafcass officers carry out safeguarding checks with the police and local authority and may speak with both parents.
In some cases, Cafcass will prepare a report that provides recommendations to the court about what arrangements would best serve the child’s welfare. These reports can be influential but are not binding on the judge.
The court process may involve several hearings. An initial hearing considers whether agreement is possible and what further evidence may be required. In more complex cases, statements, witness evidence, or expert reports may be necessary. If no agreement is reached, a final hearing will take place where a judge hears evidence and makes a binding decision.
Parents should be prepared to focus on the child’s needs rather than past grievances. Courts discourage hostile or adversarial conduct. Demonstrating a willingness to support the child’s relationship with the other parent is often viewed positively, provided it is safe to do so.
Resolving Matters Effectively
Disputes about children can be emotionally charged, but a constructive approach often leads to better outcomes. Early legal advice can clarify rights, responsibilities, and realistic expectations. It can also help parents avoid procedural errors or unnecessary escalation.
Key practical steps include:
-
Prioritising the child’s welfare above personal conflict
-
Maintaining respectful communication wherever possible
-
Keeping detailed records if concerns about safety or wellbeing arise
-
Engaging seriously with mediation or alternative dispute resolution
-
Seeking legal advice before making court applications
A well prepared and child focused approach can reduce stress and improve the likelihood of reaching agreement. Even when court involvement is unavoidable, professional guidance can help streamline the process and present your case effectively.
Child Arrangements Orders are not about winning or losing. They are about ensuring that children have stable and supportive arrangements that promote their development and wellbeing. With the right advice and preparation, many parents are able to move forward with clarity and confidence.
If you are facing a dispute about child arrangements or considering making an application to court, Penerley can provide practical and compassionate support tailored to your circumstances. Contact our family law team today to protect your child’s best interests and secure a stable future. Early advice can make a meaningful difference to both the process and the outcome.
